A heated dispute about the fate of a long-standing community garden in West End is unfolding. Authorities have released a warning against possible soil contamination in the area and the seemingly unauthorised use of a public plot for the garden, while supporters of the garden expressed skepticism over the nature and timing of recent actions taken to close the garden down.
Community Garden at Centre of Dispute
Kurilpa Commons was established on a disused state-owned block that had remained vacant for more than 90 years. The site is located within the Kurilpa peninsula, an area with a legacy of heavy industrial activity.
In February, the department fenced off the garden, warning of trespassing and potential prosecution.
It appears that the garden has been operated for six years by Growing Forward, on land belonging to the Department of Transport and Main Roads, allegedly without formal approval.
Despite these measures, community members dismantled the fencing and continued using the garden for various purposes including vegetable growing, acro yoga, and local events.
Contamination and Testing Underway
The State has flagged the possibility of soil contamination at the site, citing the peninsula’s industrial history. Previous tests in the broader area have detected substances such as coal tar, heavy metals, semi-volatile compounds and asbestos. While the department has not confirmed what contaminants are suspected at Kurilpa Commons specifically, it stated that preliminary soil test results are expected shortly.
Efforts to conduct additional soil and vegetation testing were interrupted by on-site protests from Growing Forward, who have been occupying the land since the warnings were issued.
Community Response and Concerns
Members of Growing Forward have expressed scepticism about the timing and motives of the warnings, noting the proximity of a neighbouring development. They have stated they are taking precautionary measures, such as thoroughly washing vegetables, but questioned the transparency of the government’s claims.
They view Kurilpa Commons as more than a garden—describing it as a communal space that fosters local organisation and connection. No fines or arrests have been made, despite the garden’s unauthorised status.
Next Steps
The Department of Transport and Main Roads has indicated it will assess future actions once the initial soil testing results are received. It has not confirmed whether further enforcement measures will be taken. The community group remains active on the site, pending the outcome of the State decisions.
Published 2-May-2025